Skip to content

Category: Administrative Law CasesSyndicate content

Sadeghi v MCI 2011 FC 1236 Nautral Justice credibility failure to translate form and then reliance on it

December 27, 2011 by lorne

Jurisprudence Brief: 
The Court set aside a decision where the tribunal relied on an immigration form that was not translated to the applicant.

Samaroo v MCI 2011 FC 1460 Application dismissed due to conduct of applicant--unclean hands

December 27, 2011 by lorne

Jurisprudence Brief: 
The Court refused to consider a judicial review and dismissed it due to the repeated breaches of immigration law by the applicant that included failure to report for removal.

Nadesan v MCI 2011 FC 1325 proof of identity failure to exercise discretion sextion 178 Regs

November 30, 2011 by lorne

Jurisprudence Brief: 
The court set aside a refusal based on failure to provide identity documents holding that the officer failed to exercise his discretion to consider alternate proof under section 178.

Aguilar v MCI 2011 FC 908 natural justice extrinsic evidence in file

November 24, 2011 by lorne

Jurisprudence Brief: 
The Court found a breach of natural justice when the PIF of the applicant's ex husband was in her file. This ought not to have formed part of the file and hence the applicant was denied a fair hearing.

Rajagopal v MCI 2011 FC 1277 PRRA wrong standard of risk oral hearing

November 20, 2011 by lorne

Jurisprudence Brief: 
The Court set aside a decision when the PRRA officer applied the wrong risk standard The COurt also found that as credibuility was at issue an oral hearing ought to have been convened.

Beltran v MCI 2011 FC 516 Abuse of process delay

June 20, 2011 by lorne

Jurisprudence Brief: 
The Court ordered a stay of proceedings when it found that the delay resulted in prejudice and found the proceedings to be an abuse of process.

Thiyagarajah v MCI 2011 FCJ 450 War crimes duress

June 19, 2011 by lorne

Jurisprudence Brief: 
The court upheld a finding of inadmissibility holding that although duress could apply to membership the tribunal did not err in concluding that the applicant's membership was not under duress

AMAYEANVBO v MCI 2011 FC 621 Genuine Marriage

June 10, 2011 by lorne

Jurisprudence Brief: 
The Court found a decision that a marriage was not genuine to be unreasonable because the officer ignored evidence that pointed to the marriage and made improper findings of credibility because the inconsistencies pointed to were not significant

Rana v MCI 2011 FC 318 reconsideration of order for certification

March 26, 2011 by lorne

Jurisprudence Brief: 
The Court dismissed an application to reconsider an order. The applicant on the motion had argued that as the court had decided the matter on an issue not raised in the appeal he should be allowed to seek certification. The Court dismissed the motion holding there was no new matter allowing for reconsideration.

Singh Dhaliwal v MPS 2011 FC 201 Natural Justice--unrepresented litigant costs

March 6, 2011 by lorne

Jurisprudence Brief: 
The court set aside a decision of the Appeal Division because the applicant an unrepresented appellant was denied the right to present his case. the court granted costs because the Minister ought to have consented.